Why Write A Biography of A Long-forgotten Black Broadway Star?
Updated: 6 days ago
I'm exited about my forthcoming book, Wild About Lottie Gee, which tells the story of one of the many Black actors/singers/dancers of the early 20th century whose legacy has been forgotten over time. I'll be posting here a few excerpts from the book to whet your appetite!

Why write a book about a long-forgotten star of 1920s Broadway? Gee’s story deserves telling because it addresses head-on issues of racism, colorism, and sexism that have long been part of all Black performers’ struggles for recognition. Gee bravely faced all of these headwinds, placing an important marker down for how Black women could be portrayed onstage. She was both a product of her times and rose above them, defying conventions and pushing forward even as performance styles changed. Besides restoring her importance in the history of musical theater, I hope to place her life into the complex context of the development of Black artistry as performers broke through the stereotypes that previously placed limitations on their creativity.
The 1920s were a landmark decade for Black creators in all fields. In 1920, Mamie Smith’s “Crazy Blues” was an unexpected hit, launching the craze for female blues singers. In 1921, Shuffle Along heralded a new age for Black musical theater, popularizing post–minstrel era comedy, attractive dance routines, and appealing, lightly syncopated music. In 1923, the first recording by a Black jazz band—King Oliver’s Creole Jazz Band, featuring Louis Armstrong—was released, magnifying the craze for jazz music and dance. That same year, Harlem’s Cotton Club opened its doors to wealthy white patrons who wanted to dip their toes in the emerging Black culture (although Blacks were barred from being part of the audience); soon Duke Ellington would head the band there. The craze for Black culture was blossoming, and an entire new movement across the arts—to be called the Harlem Renaissance—was rapidly taking shape. Blacks and whites alike were dancing to jazz music, attending Black shows, and reading Black poetry and stories. Conservative critics worried that the white population was being “stained” by its adoption of Black speech, music, clothing, and dance; Black social philosophers worried that the popular image of Blacks as frenetic and oversexualized would negate the work they were doing to “uplift the race.” Nonetheless, neither could turn back the public’s fascination with Black culture.
For Black performers, this was a time of opportunity that was tinged with the knowledge that there were limitations on what white, mainstream audiences would accept. Black artists faced a double bind when they sought to win widespread acceptance: they either were criticized for being “too Black” to be acceptable to a white audience or “not Black enough” in trying to overcome the limitations and stereotypes that a white audience would accept from Black actors. Gee faced even more challenges: she was Black, but light-skinned (a double bind of its own); a woman; an actress raised in a border state by a family that aspired to middle-class respectability; and a performer devoted to a pre-blues style of singing. Additionally, Gee faced emotional and physical problems that would have ended a less-determined actor’s career. Yet, she persevered and carved out a career despite the many obstacles in her way.
Colorism was common among both Blacks and whites. White audiences preferred lighter-skinned Black women on stage because they more closely hewed to European conceptions of beauty. Yet, these performers still faced all the limitations of where they could perform and what characters they could portray. While the chorus line was limited to those who were light and tan, the comedians were required to appear in blackface, one of the more pernicious legacies of minstrelsy. But blackface extended well beyond skin tones; the stereotyped minstrel roles for Black women, from nurturing Mammy to sexy vamp, were still very much expected on stage. Ironically, some members of the Black community favored lighter skin, and based a strict social hierarchy on skin color, from light to deep black; others felt threatened by their lighter-skinned peers who could more easily “pass” as white, crossing racial boundaries.
Think of all the contradictions and ironies in the fact that Gee, a Black actress who, to obtain legitimacy on the stage, was costumed like her white peers and sang in a similar style to them, while a white, Jewish performer, Sophie Tucker, had to appear in blackface early in her career so she could portray herself as an “authentic” singer of Black songs. Gee straightened her hair in a stylish bob to appear more like a contemporary, urban white flapper; Tucker wore a curly-haired wig to appear more like a “down-home” Black woman. Both privately expressed frustration with these limitations and acknowledged the ironies of their situations, but each had to come up with some kind of compromise if they wished to earn a living. While Tucker had the advantage of being white, so once she gained success she could drop the blackface illusion, Gee was locked into a classic racial bind: her mimicking American “whiteness” wasn’t going to earn her equality with “authentic” white actresses, while it drew scorn from members of her own race who felt she was “passing” as a means of avoiding prejudice.
Racial prejudice was one thing that Gee had to overcome; but there was also prejudice within the Black community—particularly that part that wished to “uplift” themselves to be acceptable to white society—against anyone who performed onstage. Jayna Brown in Babylon Girls notes how women on stage and sex workers were both seen as part of an “alternative economy,” earning their livings in careers that fell outside middle-class norms. While this allowed some Black women to earn significantly better livings and to escape the limited employment opportunities that were open to them, the flip side was the general condemnation they felt from the broader Black community. While noting that it was their graceful, moving bodies—often revealingly dressed to emphasize their busts and legs—was the biggest audience draw for Black shows, the critics nonetheless tut-tutted when they felt a particular actress went too far. They often applauded Lottie Gee for her demure performances and polished presentation; ironically, this made her work less attractive to these same critics who were more impressed by her racier peers, particularly the sexy, high-stepping chorines.
Another prejudice that Gee faced could be described as “Old-Southism”: the presumption that all Black performers were children of the “old plantation,” who enjoyed idyllic childhoods living a simple life, benefitting from the largesse of their white neighbors. Not only was this stereotyped image of the “old South” grossly wrong, obscuring centuries of blatant racist treatment of the Black population there, but Gee, like most other Black stage stars of this period, was raised in the urban North in Kentucky, just across from the major metropolis of Cincinnati, Ohio; her family aspired to the mainstream values of propriety and success that defined the New Negro movement. Like Kentucky that was called a “border” state because it wavered between antipathy to and sympathy for its enslaved population during the Civil War, the Gee family had to negotiate its own borderline identity. Gee spent her life pushing against borders, the limitations that could have hampered her stage success.
Related to this was the common idea that Blacks were “natural” performers, with God-given talents. This was another double-edged sword; it denied Blacks the agency that they had in creating their own music and dance, attributing it only to their DNA. Highly trained theater artists like Lottie Gee had to repeat this trope in their interactions with the press, winning approval by denying their legitimate training. Gaining this training was not easy; many conventional doors for preparing to be an actor, singer, or dancer were closed to them; they couldn’t be admitted to white conservatories or theatrical or dance schools. Their considerable achievement in defying these odds to gain their talents was hidden behind the minstrel mask.
Gee’s triumphant performance in Shuffle Along both heralded a new age for Black theater but also swept away an entire performance style that was her natural métier. She was born at a time when Black actors sought legitimacy by emulating turn-of-the-century white theatrical models; in musical comedy, this meant following the typical operetta plots, characters, and song styles that were popularized through the works of white composers like Victor Herbert. In this highly idealized world, bold young men struggle against obstacles to win the hands of fair maidens, all set to tuneful melodies. Operetta never questioned the social hierarchy, but reinforced it through underscoring the class privileges that it promoted. Gee was cast as a female lead (or prima donna)—the dainty, innocent, ideal woman whose laudable behavior and tasteful costumes made her an ideal prize for the male lead. However, although not apparent at the time, operetta was about to be swept away by the Jazz Age.
Gee had the misfortune of being born in an era when the image of Black performers was rapidly changing; new styles were being introduced that overshadowed earlier ones. She could not or would not adapt to please the shifting audiences, in both the Black and white worlds, for reasons we cannot know. This was an additional dilemma that, on top of her race and gender, stymied her career. But, in her day, for a number of Black women who were just breaking into the theatrical world, Gee was a lodestar, a model of what was possible, and even to some a mentor. Without Gee, there would be no Florence Mills or Josephine Baker; both actresses acknowledged the value of her friendship and support. Dozens of future Black women headliners were admirers of Gee’s work as an actress, singer, and dancer; all hoped to equal her achievement.
Although Gee had several opportunities, she never made a record, and her skills were never captured on film. Her commitment to perform her stage repertoire—a combination of traditional spirituals and Broadway and pop songs—along with her stage-trained singing style, may have limited her appeal to record producers. Other contemporary Black actresses were able to make this transition, often by recording songs from the blues repertoire and other “acceptable” material for Black vocalists. For some reason, Gee did not cross over; she did not or could not adapt her act to what was expected of a Black performer.
Early Black theater managers had to work within the constraints of what was acceptable to a broader audience while they aspired to create “legitimate” shows of their own that they hoped would establish—once and for all—that Black writers, actors, singers, and dancers could equal the “sophisticated” work of their white counterparts—with the added dash of excitement coming from their authentic portrayal of Black life through the syncopated rhythms of their music and dance, and the earthy satirical comedy that they honed through years of working in minstrelsy and vaudeville. Most discovered that they had to make a compromise between broad minstrel stereotypes and their attempts to present what was considered more “refined” entertainment.
This was the theatrical world that first attracted the attention of young Lottie Gee. While she benefited from the work of her predecessors to legitimize and popularize Black performance, she still struggled with an environment that could be uniquely difficult for a Black woman to navigate. While buffeted by the winds of prejudice due to her color and gender, and in many ways abused by her closest friends and promoters, Gee grabbed opportunities to “lift herself up” as an escape from an otherwise limited world. She made a conscious decision to become an actor against the wishes of her parents, who certainly did not want their daughter to seek a career on stage. Gee rarely was discouraged by the obstacles that were thrown in her way, but always tried to rebuild her career, having faith in her training and a strong belief in the actor’s calling. She was also notably supportive of her peers who were seeking stage success, a remarkable quality given that promoting the work of others was seen as counterproductive to one’s own success.
That a Black actress, singer, and dancer of the early twentieth century is largely forgotten today should come as no surprise; Black lives are often erased from cultural histories. Lost materials—from play scripts to scores—and lack of recorded evidence on sound recordings or films make tracking the innovative work of Black stars even more difficult. Contemporary accounts were often encumbered by stereotypes and the limitations of the white critical gaze when it was directed toward Black performers. Too often critics were blindered by the belief that Blacks should speak, sing, and dance in a particular “authentic” way, a demand that was not made of contemporary white performers.
A biography is one way to restore a life; a biography that places that life within the context of its cultural and social history can also illuminate issues that transcend an individual’s struggles. Restoration is the first step toward understanding and restitution; our cultural history is enriched if we look beyond the boldface names to embrace a wider, deeper understanding of the variety of Black expression that occurred to address each era’s particular needs. What was progressive in its day may appear hopelessly antiquated now, but it’s important to consider the context of both individual performers and their milieu to uncover their true revolutionary impact. This legacy should not be forgotten even as our norms and tastes change, because they supply an important corrective to past histories and give current performers perspective on their role in the continuing struggle for artistic equality.
In reconstructing Gee’s professional life I have had to rely on contemporary reviews, which were often colored by the prejudice of the reviewers themselves. White critics were the most prejudiced, but newspapers that catered to a Black audience also were limited in their coverage of the theater. Descriptions of Gee’s performances are perfunctory, sometimes giving the names of songs that she performed and generic descriptions of her singing style, but most often focusing on her lavish costumes. Even during her period of greatest popularity on Broadway, there is little reliable description of her singing, dancing, or stage presence. And interviews in the press were often heavily doctored by the writers, putting words into the mouths of their subjects, and were further colored by Gee’s need to promote a certain image. Besides one remarkably frank interview given in 1930, conducted at a particularly low point of her career, Gee’s true personality is shrouded in the reports of the journalists of her day.
Comments